On measuring freedom of the press in India
The article critically examines the World Press Freedom Index, published by Reporters Without Borders, which ranks India at 157. It questions the methodology and criteria of such global rankings, highlighting that they often fail to account for societal diversity, cultural contexts, and the quality of journalism itself. The author points out that while some countries with less democratic traditions rank higher, the index does not consider issues like racism in the 'freest' press. The article also notes the decline in press freedom in India, citing the rare occurrence of press conferences by the Prime Minister and the increasing control exerted by both state and market forces on the media, leading to a one-way communication street in political discourse. It concludes that while rankings are blunt instruments, they do indicate broad patterns of stress on the Indian media.
The article critically examines the World Press Freedom Index, published by Reporters Without Borders, which ranks India at 157. It questions the methodology and criteria of such global rankings, highlighting that they often fail to account for societal diversity, cultural contexts, and the quality of journalism itself. The author points out that while some countries with less democratic traditions rank higher, the index does not consider issues like racism in the 'freest' press. The article also notes the decline in press freedom in India, citing the rare occurrence of press conferences by the Prime Minister and the increasing control exerted by both state and market forces on the media, leading to a one-way communication street in political discourse. It concludes that while rankings are blunt instruments, they do indicate broad patterns of stress on the Indian media.
Exam linkage
GS Paper II - Indian Polity and Governance: Fundamental Rights (Freedom of Speech and Expression), Role of Media, Government policies and interventions for development in various sectors and issues arising out of their design and implementation.
Syllabus mapping
This topic appears in Mains
Questions on Indian Polity & Governance come up regularly in GS papers. Practice writing an answer — and see exactly what earns marks.